Symonds, Tristan, Grant, Andrea, Doma, Kenji, Hinton, Darren, Wilkinson, Matthew, and Morse, Levi (2022) The efficacy of topical preparations in reducing the incidence of Cutibacterium acnes at the start and conclusion of total shoulder arthroplasty: a randomized controlled trial. Journal of Shoulder and Elbow Surgery, 31 (6). pp. 1115-1121.

PDF (Published Version) - Published Version Restricted to Repository staff only

 

5

1

Abstract

Background: Preoperative skin preparations for total shoulder arthroplasty (TSA) are not standardized for Cutibacterium acnes eradication. Topical benzyl peroxide (BPO) and benzyl peroxide with clindamycin (BPO-C) have been shown to reduce the bacterial load of C acnes on the skin. Our aim was to investigate whether preoperative application of these topical antimicrobials reduced superficial colonization and deep tissue inoculation of C acnes in patients undergoing TSA.

Methods: In a prospective, single-blinded randomized controlled trial, 101 patients undergoing primary TSA were randomized to receive either topical pHisoHex (hexachlorophene [1% triclosan; sodium benzoate, 5 mg/mL; and benzyl alcohol, 5 mg/mL]) (n = 35), 5% BPO (n = 33), or 5% BPO with 1% clindamycin (n = 33). Skin swabs obtained prior to topical application and after topical application before surgery, as well as 3 intraoperative swabs (dermis after incision, on joint capsule entry, and dermis at wound closure), were cultured. The primary outcome was positive culture findings and successful decolonization.

Results: All 3 topical preparations were effective in decreasing the rate of C acnes. The application of pHisoHex reduced skin colonization by 50%, BPO reduced skin colonization by 73.7%, and BPO-C reduced skin colonization by 81.5%. The topical preparation of BPO-C was more effective in decreasing the rate of C acnes at the preoperative and intraoperative swab time points compared with pHisoHex and BPO (P = .003). Failure to eradicate C acnes with topical preparations consistently resulted in deep tissue inoculation. There was an increase in the C acnes contamination rate on the skin during closure (33%) compared with skin cultures taken at surgery commencement (22%).

Conclusion: Topical application of BPO and BPO-C preoperatively is more effective than pHisoHex in reducing colonization and contamination of the surgical field with C acnes in patients undergoing TSA.

Actions (Repository Staff Only)

Item Control Page