Risk and protective factors for violent behaviour and incarceration for Indigenous and non-Indigenous men in North Queensland

Honorato, Bronwyn Anne (2018) Risk and protective factors for violent behaviour and incarceration for Indigenous and non-Indigenous men in North Queensland. PhD thesis, James Cook University.

[img]
Preview
PDF (Thesis)
Download (2MB) | Preview
View at Publisher Website: https://doi.org/10.25903/5cf9a61a0851b
 
14


Abstract

Principal Objectives

Very high rates of interpersonal violence and incarceration are reported for men in North Queensland, with very little empirical research existing investigating the factors influencing these phenomena. To investigate these factors, a two-phase exploratory research project was designed and implemented. Phase 1 included conducting in-depth interviews to gather qualitative data, which was then used to inform development of surveys used for Phase 2, the quantitative study.

Research question: "What are the risk and protective factors associated with perpetrating violence and incarceration for Indigenous and non-Indigenous men in North Queensland, Australia?"

The aims of the project were to explore factors for men in North Queensland that may be associated with an: (1) increase the risk of violent behaviour; (2) reduce the risk of violent behaviour; (3) increase the risk of incarceration; (4) reduce the risk of incarceration; and (5) that may differ for Indigenous compared with non-Indigenous men.

Methodology

Phase 1 included conducting in depth interviews with participants to provide qualitative data; while Phase 2, informed by the data from Phase 1, involved surveying a larger group of participants to enable quantitative analysis of data. A manager from Lotus Glen Correctional Centre (LGCC) was delegated to recruit inmates from within the prison. Eligibility criteria included being aged 18 years or over, able to read and write English, and sentenced or on remand for violent offences. Excluded were those with mental or physical health issues and if deemed unsuitable for any reason by the LGCC manager. Information sheets were provided to the inmates by the manager, and consent forms were signed. The researcher was then contacted to arrange a time to conduct data collection. A non-randomised recruitment method was used for community participants for Phase 1, as information was sought from a small, 'expert' group for whom the research question was significant. Snowball sampling was used to recruit survey participants for Phase 2. Eligibility for Phase 2 included being male, aged over 18 years, and residing or having grown up in North Queensland, including the Torres Strait Islands. Indigenous Australian research advisors were consulted to ensure cultural appropriateness for all phases of the project.

Phase 1. Using an Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (IPA) framework, interviews were conducted, then transcribed verbatim. Data was managed and coded using NVivo software.

Phase 2. The survey was developed using demographic information, interview data from Phase 1 and existing research. The online survey (including information sheet and electronic consent) was accessed by community participants via SurveyMonkey, while prison inmates completed a paper survey. Univariate and multivariate logistic regressions were used to estimate odds ratios (ORs) for each independent variable for violent compared with non-violent and incarcerated compared with non-incarcerated participants. Cross tabulations were used to determine if differences in significant associations existed for Indigenous and non-Indigenous participants between both of the dependent variables and each categorical independent variable.

Results

Phase 1. The sample included 26 Indigenous and 13 non-Indigenous Australian participants, including 19 prison inmates. Overall, for Indigenous participants, and for incarcerated participants adverse family and childhood factors were the most influential category of risk factors for violent behaviour and incarceration, while socio-economic factors were the most important theme for non-Indigenous participants. The next most important themes were personal attributes, socio-economic factors, witnessing or a history of violence, and peer group and social influences. Non-Indigenous participants also frequently mentioned substance use and abuse. Overall, the most common protective factor themes were having good role models and mentors. Next were personal attributes, family and childhood factors, coping skills, and socioeconomic factors. For Indigenous participants extracurricular activities were commonly mentioned, while non-Indigenous participants believed socio-economic factors were very important.

A common trajectory from trauma to incarceration was also identified for a sample of incarcerated participants (n=11) during this study. This trajectory, while not identified as a causal path for violence or incarceration per se, included childhood or adolescent trauma, a lack of support or treatment for trauma, substance abuse to mask the pain, and a 'brain snap' (sudden action, without conscious thought) precipitating a violent offence, resulting in incarceration.

Phase 2. The survey was completed by 85 men (of whom 30 were Indigenous) from North and Far North Queensland, including 37 inmates, and 48 community members. Frequent cannabis use increased the risk of perpetration of violence towards others, while a higher education level reduced the risk. When comparing cultural groups, significant associations were revealed for both alcohol and cannabis use with violence for non-Indigenous, but not for Indigenous participants. Cannabis use and religious beliefs increased the risk of incarceration, while higher education levels, positive childhood events and being in a relationship were protective. Comparison of cultural groups revealed significant associations between religious beliefs and incarceration for Indigenous but not for non-Indigenous participants. Alcohol and cannabis use were significantly associated with incarceration for non-Indigenous, but not for Indigenous participants.

Principal Conclusions

This is one of the first explorative studies of this kind conducted in North Queensland, with Indigenous and non-Indigenous Australians, including prison inmates. Early intervention and treatment efforts focusing on young males, particularly users, or those at risk of using cannabis, could help to reduce violence and incarceration rates for future generations. The use of culturally appropriate assessment tools is also critical, as many tools are not validated for use with Indigenous Australians, or with prison inmates. This would aid diagnosis, treatment plans and, for inmates, rehabilitation management.

The importance of social determinants, including childhood upbringing and experiences, and education to a tertiary or vocational level are highlighted in this study. The socioeconomic indicators of regional and remote communities, particularly Indigenous communities, are often far worse than urban populations, with little or no constructive economic activity, educational, or employment options available. Assisting men to gain meaningful employment, identifying needs, and developing individual strengths to reduce violent behaviour and incarceration may allow more men to become constructive, functioning contributors to society. Breaking the cycle of violence and incarceration for these men requires the public health community, educators, legislators, community leaders and young people to work towards reducing risks and increasing strengths and presenting alternate pathways for disadvantaged young people.

Item ID: 58549
Item Type: Thesis (PhD)
Keywords: male prison inmates, incarceration, trauma, violent offending, Indigenous, non-Indigenous, North Queensland
Related URLs:
Copyright Information: Copyright © 2018 Bronwyn Anne Honorato.
Additional Information:

Publications arising from this thesis are available from the Related URLs field. The publications are:

Honorato, Bronwyn, Caltabiano, Nerina, and Clough, Alan R. (2016) From trauma to incarceration: exploring the trajectory in a qualitative study in male prison inmates from north Queensland, Australia. Health & Justice, 4 (3). pp. 1-10.

Date Deposited: 07 Jun 2019 00:11
FoR Codes: 11 MEDICAL AND HEALTH SCIENCES > 1117 Public Health and Health Services > 111701 Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health @ 80%
11 MEDICAL AND HEALTH SCIENCES > 1117 Public Health and Health Services > 111799 Public Health and Health Services not elsewhere classified @ 20%
SEO Codes: 92 HEALTH > 9203 Indigenous Health > 920399 Indigenous Health not elsewhere classified @ 100%
Downloads: Total: 14
Last 12 Months: 14
More Statistics

Actions (Repository Staff Only)

Item Control Page Item Control Page